The truth about 'Digital Wills'

In England and Wales, the concept of a "digital will" does not legally exist due to the stringent formal requirements for will creation and execution set forth in the Wills Act 1837 and subsequent legal interpretations. These requirements are designed to prevent fraud and ensure the testator's intentions are clear and unequivocal. Here are several reasons explaining the absence of digital wills:

Legal Formalities and the Wills Act 1837

The Wills Act 1837, which governs the creation of wills in England and Wales, mandates specific formalities that must be observed for a will to be valid:

1. Writing Requirement: A will must be in writing, which means it must be on paper.
2. Signature Requirement: The testator must sign the will with a wet signature.
3. Witness Requirement: The will must be signed in the presence of at least two witnesses, who also sign the document.

These requirements are rooted in a historical context aiming to minimise fraud and ensure the authenticity of the will. The tactile, physical nature of a written document is seen as a safeguard against forgery and coercion.

Witnessing and Fraud Prevention

One of the primary reasons digital wills are not recognised is the difficulty in ensuring the integrity of the witnessing process in a digital format. Witnesses provide an essential safeguard by confirming the testator’s identity, their understanding of the will, and their voluntary signing of it. In a digital context, ensuring the presence of witnesses and their proper identification poses significant challenges. The potential for digital manipulation or fraud (e.g., forged digital signatures or manipulated electronic documents) remains a substantial concern.

Legislative and Judicial Reluctance

There has been legislative and judicial reluctance to adapt the stringent formal requirements to accommodate digital formats. This conservatism stems from a desire to uphold the reliability and trustworthiness of wills. Any move towards accepting digital wills would require robust mechanisms to verify the authenticity of electronic signatures and the identity of witnesses, which currently do not exist in a sufficiently secure form.

Lack of Technological Infrastructure

The legal infrastructure and technology required to support digital wills in a manner that meets the high standards of proof and security needed for such important documents are not yet adequately developed. For instance, digital signatures, while increasingly used in various domains, do not yet offer the same level of assurance as physical signatures witnessed in person. There are concerns about the potential for digital signatures to be hacked, duplicated, or otherwise misused.

Recent Developments and Temporary Changes

The COVID-19 pandemic did prompt some temporary changes, such as the acceptance of remote witnessing via video link, but these adaptations were specifically tailored to address the extraordinary circumstances of the pandemic and were not intended as a permanent shift towards digital wills. These changes highlighted the potential for modernisation but also underscored the challenges involved in ensuring the security and authenticity of the will-making process in a digital environment.

Future Prospects

While the current legal framework does not accommodate digital wills, there is growing recognition of the need to modernise the law to keep pace with technological advancements. The Law Commission of England and Wales has been reviewing the law concerning wills, including the potential for digital wills. However, any significant changes will likely be cautious and gradual, prioritising the need to protect against fraud and maintain the integrity of the will-making process.

5-Step To-Do List for Digital Will Considerations

1. Understand Current Legal Requirements:
   • Familiarise yourself with the Wills Act 1837 requirements for creating a valid will in England and Wales.
2. Consider Traditional Will Options:
   • Given the current legal framework, ensure your will is written, signed, and witnessed according to traditional requirements to avoid invalidation.
3. Stay Informed About Legal Changes:
   • Keep up-to-date with potential legislative changes or Law Commission reports that might impact the future acceptance of digital wills.
4. Evaluate Technological Tools:
   • While digital wills are not legally recognised, explore secure digital tools for drafting and storing your will, but ensure the final document complies with current laws.
5. Seek Professional Advice:
   • Consult with legal professionals who specialise in estate planning to ensure your will meets all legal requirements and to stay informed about any developments in digital wills.

What to Do Next

Should you wish to speak to someone, we're always on hand to expand or clarify anything you're unsure about. It's our purpose to make sure you're fully informed before making any decisions, and you don't even have to be a customer.

Click here to get in touch or call us using the number at the top of this page.

Our guarantee: we are part of the Best Foundation, a voluntarily regulated body for the Estate Planning industry. As a member of the foundation, we hold ourselves accountable to providing the best professional standards, and upholding ethical values for all our customers.